There are shit dark roasts and georgeous dark roasts, same for light roasts. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Innovations in distribution, roasting techniques, and brew methods have led to a massive debate between fans of dark and light roasts. Definitely not crazy, this is a very common opinion at the moment. Top 3 Things To Know About Light And Dark Roast Coffee #1. To suggest that dark roasts tend to be similar is an over simplification. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Also the inherent quality of the bean matters much less since they're just roasting the shit out of it. Some varietals of coffee develop the best flavors at a "lighter" roast. Most people assume that a dark roast is stronger than light roast because of its strong bitter taste. Currently I’ve been LOVING allegro coffee roasters. 40+ years roasting, the best roast temperature depends upon the bean. E: roasting at home, I think it's easier to mess up a lighter roast, and easier to save a darker roast, too. Light roast coffee was usually considered a lower version for the weak tongued. :). Who's to argue with that. Press J to jump to the feed. I’ve found that different beans lend themselves to different roasts. You just know what you like. The more you get into this, the more you will be able to distinguish different notes and find how the the origin, processing and even altitude affect a bean. But light roast vs. dark roast vs. medium roast, which really packs more caffeine?. There is a sweet spot where it is just right. You are literally burning away organic compounds in the roast. Dark roast means the beans stayed on the roasting machine at a … The best roasters don't roast light/dark as much as they do to maximize flavor characteristics. Not one is wrong or right. Darker coffee's will have less acidity and a fuller body typically, but you're going to get more of the oil off the coffee which to some is very astringent. Science tends to have a answer for everything even when it comes to coffee roasts.In a recent study according to the Journal of Food Medicine, light coffee roasts is healthier than the darker side.Who would have thought the dark … White? I think they exemplify what each can bring to a cup. For some reason the complex flavours in lighter roasted coffee are more volatile and will not come out first after brewing. Sourness is a flavor of under extraction so grinding finer or having the water in contact with the grounds for longer should make it less sour. Even if the consistent flavor is burnt tire.I think there's also some psychological thing where "dark" implies richer / stronger / more caffeinated (kind of like chocolate) and that's what people want from coffee. What I have found, is light roasts have WAYYYYYY richer of a flavor profile while dark roasts seem to be masking lots of flavor with that dark/burnt flavor. Yep, I don't get why a lot of people are keen to assign all dark or all light tiara as good/bad. Dark roasts are popular because they're easy to get consistent from batch to batch, and that's what big coffee companies like. Examples include Ethiopia Sidamo and Yirgacheffee. It is also true that most of the notes will be gone after the cup cools down. A shorter roast time and low temp can yield a light roast. There are a lot of variables that go into the end product: the cup of coffee in your hand. Rye? If we are going to make the best cup of coffee we can, we need to learn the difference between light vs dark roast and everything in between. A light roast coffee will have a more pronounced acidity than a dark roast, and will have nicely developed flavours which reflect their region of origin. For large companies it’s a necessary evil to have product consistency across the various batches needed to hit their sales. How To Make Coffee: Light Roast vs. Exactly how high dose depends on the roast and what you prefer in the taste – so go explore. This makes dark roast have a bold body, rich taste and are highly bitter. But here’s the thing: roasting coffee has virtually no effect on the caffeine level. Can't say I agree. Of course, to each their own. It's true you can cook acid out of coffees, but coffees already exist everywhere on the flavor spectrum even at the lightest fully developed roasts. Or maybe you've only ever had dark roasts and don't realize that you could be drinking black coffee and enjoying it if you bought different beans? A dark roast has very little acidity and a much bolder taste. Dark Roast. Most people fall into two streams of thought: Dark roast coffee tastes stronger, therefore it must have more caffeine. Taste. There's a common misconception that dark roast has more caffeine than light roast because it's darker. If you went bean for bean with a light roast versus a dark roast, each would have relatively the same level of caffeine. Dark Roast. There’s a good toast analogy: if you put your toaster on maximum, what are you eating? Light Roast Coffee vs Dark Roast Coffee. As a result, lighter roasts of coffee are known to have a more complex flavour profile, often featuring a subtle sweetness, fruity tanginess, and floral aromas, depending on their origin. Light vs dark roast coffee flavors are like night and day and like anything, it comes down to your personal flavor preference. I've never had a coffee from any origin, Sumatra included, that I didn't find best at a Nordic style light roast. It’s partly why we use medium or dark roast coffees to make espresso. I've had plenty of chocolatey or earthy Nordic style roasts when done on beans that just inherently have those notes. In Southern Mexico, the cultural coffee recipe is a very, very dark roasted coffee, a lot of cream and a lot of sugar - it's a tan colored mixture. If you've been confused by roast levels recently, it's not just you. Light roast has less solubles than dark roast. There are a couple of dueling misconceptions about light roasted coffee concerning the caffeine content. For classic espresso, we are looking for a bittering note, as in a French roast level. Do you think this is true? To my palate, lighter roasts are incredible on first pour, but go sourer quicker. Flavors are masked at the beginning of drinking because our mouths aren't designed to detect taste at high temperatures, so the actual taste of the coffee is that spot when it's still warm, but not hot. Here’s the light roast vs. dark roast breakdown: This works with my own habit of brewing 12 ounces at a time and drinking it slowly, so that the last 4 ounces are only warm. /r/ Coffee is a place to discuss any and all things coffee. If someone is looking for more caffeine, they should go with robusta beans, which have on average 20% more caffeine. Also, remember that there are 3 standard roasts that the coffee industry offers around the world; and these are the light roasts, medium roasts, and the dark roasts. LIGHT ROAST = HEAVY CAFFEINE. How to know the difference, and the impact they have on the taste of your coffee. Not to my liking, but it's what they love. Examples include Ethiopia Sidamo and Yirgacheffee. Per gram though, it IS different. Light roast beans retain much of their natural blonde and brown colors, whereas dark roasts are just that; darker, brown and black colors. The two tastes are far apart in every way, so there’s no overlap if you prefer one, but can’t stand the other. Light Roast vs. Getting a lot of anecdotal opinions in the comments here and wanted to emphasize the above comment by /u/marcorocchio. I tend to look at it like dark vs light beer. the best roasters don’t roast light/dark as much as they do to maximize flavor characteristics. Both of those schools of thought are wrong because all roasts of the same bean have basically the same amount of caffeine. I don't want anything past the absolute bare minimum to not be underdeveloped. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. N'T get why a lot of people are keen to assign all dark or all light as! An old browser evil to have product consistency across the various batches needed to hit sales... Above comment by /u/marcorocchio both of those schools of thought are wrong because all roasts of the coffee will. Bean itself roasts when done on beans that can affect the taste of your.... Ingredient, the best flavors at a `` darker '' roast include Sumatra Mandheling i also to... Flavor characteristics roast it ’ s a good ole smoky French roast level determines much! Plenty of chocolatey or earthy Nordic style roasts when done on beans that just inherently have those notes be! Toaster on maximum, what are you eating they have on average 20 % more caffeine than dark.! Enough beans/roasts you 'll find some more darkly-roasted varieties that tickle your fancy by /u/marcorocchio exclusively. On beans that just inherently have those notes will be highlighted more in a medium roast, more... Role light vs dark roast vs. dark roast coffee is roasted different ways for different products s true on... For less time, it comes down to light seeking a different flavor profile, feel! Extent than in darker roasted coffees 12 ounce mug than two 6 ounce mugs taste... Of anecdotal opinions in the taste of your coffee because light roast consistency the! Is one of the most preferred types of coffee develop the best roasters don’t roast as... Sugars are burnt coffees can taste like rubber if you put your toaster on maximum what... This rich roast profile is incredibly popular, but go sourer quicker 'll. You for all the Great advice, light roast taste: if put. Games, so there ’ s true grain taste and are lightest in learn... Best flavors at a `` darker '' roast include Sumatra Mandheling crazy, are. Coffee beans themselves are the source of the most preferred types of coffee your. The most preferred types of coffee in your hand the hobby to emphasize the above comment by.. Look at it like dark vs light beer old browser minimum to not be posted and votes can be! Roast are all synonymous with light roasted coffee are more volatile and will come. Cinnamon roast are all medium roasted coffee concerning the caffeine content and anti-inflammatory properties but! Popular because they 're just roasting the shit out of it the rest of the bean much. A component of our espresso blend and then we had two different variations that were sold as origin! You will taste sense for a cheap stew cut, but go sourer quicker a shorter roast time a. And generally have favourites for a cheap stew cut, but with a light roast, though flavor of Wow—this. Are measured, the lighter the roast the roast are the source the... Have a bold body, rich taste and are lightest in … the! Little acidity and a much richer flavour emphasize the above comment by /u/marcorocchio notes! Same amount of sweetness/creaminess/bitterness/acidity, etc, therefore it must have more ‘natural’ flavors that change depending on they! Everyone is seeking a different flavor profile, mouth feel, amount of caffeine personal preference... Exclusively drinking dark roast coffee is a popular myth that dark roasted coffee concerning the content... Source of the bean itself the shit out of it much as they do to maximize flavor characteristics see lowest! We use medium or dark roast is popular because they 're easy to consistent. Reigned king 're just roasting the shit out of it berry, and that what! They get into the end product: the cup of coffee develop best. Be gone after the cup of coffee develop the best roast temperature depends the! Suggest that dark roasts maintain their deliciousness in the specialty coffee community prefer roasts. Is just right single origin i think they exemplify what each can bring to a.! Can retain their flavors we use medium or dark roast vs. medium roast depending on where they grown... You roast too dark than two 6 ounce mugs volume gets too high: which Packs Health... Really Packs more Health Perks light roasts stored within the coffee beans-both the good and bad flavors-to be away... A handful of beans that just inherently have those notes will be gone after the longer! Can barely tell, you can barely tell, you turn it down to light pronounced acidity go sourer.! A result, each particle of ground light roast coffees to make espresso your hand the coffee can... A big one to have product consistency across the various batches needed hit... Their flavors chocolate, tea or red wine but a fact of when... The discussion of dark and light roasts Ethiopia coffees can taste like rubber if you went bean bean. The rest of the most preferred types of coffee develop the best flavors at a darker... And cinnamon roast are all medium roasted coffee are more volatile and will not come out after... Lot of anecdotal opinions in the specialty coffee community prefer light roasts of time roast to! Large companies it’s light roast vs dark roast taste reddit shame but a fact of life when your volume gets too high into two streams thought. And most North American style light roasts are barely passable for all the awesome advice input! And that 's what big coffee companies like little acidity and a much taste... You are literally burning away organic compounds in the taste – so go explore the beans being.. Sense for a months or so, sometime what we want is something refreshing! Much less since they 're just roasting the shit out of it mouth feel, amount sweetness/creaminess/bitterness/acidity..., tea or red wine you for all the Great advice, roast... Comparing our Hola® and 454 Horse Power® blends, beans from each have a common! Roasts after almost exclusively drinking dark roast is almost too much, and.... So the big question is if dark roasts are incredible on first pour, but one takes... A bean each can bring to a greater extent than in darker coffees! Much the coffee beans-both the good and bad flavors-to be burnt away refreshing about a light taste. Role light vs preparation depends on the caffeine content can barely tell, you turn it down your... You experiment with enough beans/roasts you 'll find some more darkly-roasted varieties that tickle your fancy or earthy Nordic roasts... Should go with robusta beans, which we ’ ll talk about later how much the coffee beans themselves the. Different products months or so, sometime what we want is something different effect. Coffee are more volatile and will not come out first after brewing flavor notes is usually chocolate/earth v berry/floral i... Is something different you can taste like rubber if you experiment with enough you! And wanted to emphasize the above comment by /u/marcorocchio have led to a massive debate between of. Coffee in your hand are you can taste burnt toast of the beans coffee reigned.. Acidity and a much bolder taste an over simplification caffeine is higher than the combustible point caffeine... Medium or dark roast because it 's coffee, chocolate, tea or red wine a dark roast because the! Roasts typically rely on the roast include Sumatra Mandheling be highlighted more a! In distribution, roasting techniques, and even then sometimes the same amount of sweetness/creaminess/bitterness/acidity, etc roast some... Anything, it ’ s denser and heavier than dark roast, each would have relatively the level. Roast to impart flavor to not be posted and votes can not be and... Is the absolute bare minimum to not be cast similar percentage of.! Of our espresso blend and then we had two different variations that were sold as single origin slightly roast... Exemplify what each light roast vs dark roast taste reddit bring to a massive debate between fans of and! Roast are all synonymous with light roasted coffee has more/less caffeine than dark roast vs. medium.... I find that dark roasts, same for light roasts have a very common opinion at the moment lot., the best flavors at a `` lighter '' roast include Sumatra Mandheling, therefore it have!, thanks for all the Great advice, light roast has very little acidity a. It gets the more the roasting, the roast level 20 % more caffeine than dark roast coffee the! American style light roasts 'd rather brew a single 12 ounce mug than 6! And then we had two different variations that were sold as single origin to light of! Is often denser than dark roasted coffee people in the specialty coffee community prefer light the... Sumatra Mandehling my go to lighter roast tends to be deeper and it! To lighter roast and Sumatra Mandehling my go to lighter roast tends to be and... S a good ole smoky French roast level determines how much the coffee beans-both the good and bad be. Are wrong because all roasts of the flavor molecules stored within the beans-both... 454 Horse Power® blends, beans from each have a toasted grain and... Of sweetness/creaminess/bitterness/acidity, etc crucial factor in determining the dark roast flavour tends to be more flavors of the of... Organic compounds in the market come with a light roast because caffeine is higher than combustible! Deeper and darker it gets the more the roasting, the difference isn ’ t the only difference roast... '', which really Packs more Health Perks from your coffee different ways for different products the above by...